Minister Rejects Imran Khan’s Jail Letter to Chief Justices as False

Federal Minister Tariq Fazal Chaudhry has called the PTI founder's jail letter to the chief justices false and contrary to facts. He denied claims of solitary confinement and denial of medical care.

Minister Rejects Imran Khan’s Jail Letter to Chief Justices as False
Image: Zacharie Grossen / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0
At a glance
  • Tariq Fazal Chaudhry called the PTI founder's letter to the chief justices false and contrary to facts.
  • He denied claims of 22-hour solitary confinement and of being denied medical care, books or television.
  • He said the PTI founder had been taken for check-ups eight times and that doctors found his health satisfactory.
  • He said the PTI founder could obtain relief only through the courts.

Federal Minister for Parliamentary Affairs Tariq Fazal Chaudhry has dismissed a letter written from jail by PTI founder Imran Khan to the chief justices as false and contrary to facts. Speaking to the media at Parliament House in Islamabad on Monday, he said the complaints made in the letter had no basis.

The minister went through the main points one by one, covering prison conditions, medical treatment and compliance with court orders. He also used the occasion to defend the conviction that put the PTI founder behind bars.

8
times the PTI founder was taken for check-ups, per the minister
22 hrs
daily solitary confinement alleged in the letter, denied by the minister
£190m
sum at the centre of the corruption case
450 kanals
land the minister said was gifted in return

Minister rejects the claims in the Imran Khan letter

According to the minister, the Imran Khan letter alleged that the PTI founder was held in solitary confinement for 22 hours a day. He called the allegation baseless and said it was untrue that the PTI founder had been denied books or television.

He also rejected the claims that medical facilities were being withheld and that court orders were not being implemented. Both, he said, were unfounded.

Tariq Fazal Chaudhry said all facilities were available to the PTI founder in jail, including food of his own choice. He went further and described him as the most privileged prisoner in Pakistan at present.

Claims in the letter and the minister's response
Claim attributed to the letter Minister's response
22 hours of solitary confinement daily Baseless; all facilities available in jail
Denial of medical facilities Weekly reviews by medical experts; eight check-ups outside jail
Denial of books and television Denied; all facilities provided
Court orders not implemented Unfounded
imran khan letter: Key numbers
imran khan letter: Key numbers

Medical care and health checks

On health, the minister said the letter's claims were incorrect. He said medical experts examine and review the PTI founder's condition every week.

When specialists are required, he said, the prisoner is taken out of jail to the best available medical facility. The PTI founder has been taken to PIMS eight times for check-ups, and doctors have described his health as satisfactory, he added.

The minister also said a doctor from London, who has practised in Pakistan as well, was called in to examine the PTI founder's blood pressure. According to him, the reading was found to be satisfactory.

He stressed that the government regards the PTI founder's facilities, medical care and good health in jail as its own responsibility. The government had not been negligent so far, he said, and would not allow negligence in the future.

NRO remark and the £190 million case

The minister said the letter was, in effect, a request for an NRO. He remarked that those who used to taunt others with the NRO label were now seeking one for themselves.

He maintained that the PTI founder could obtain relief only through the courts. He also rejected the idea of political victimisation, saying the PTI founder was in jail because he had been convicted in the £190 million corruption case.

Describing the case, Tariq Fazal Chaudhry said the £190 million was meant to reach the national treasury but was instead transferred to Malik Riaz's account. In return, he said, Malik Riaz gifted the PTI founder around 450 kanals of land. These are the minister's assertions, and he insisted the case rests on clear and solid evidence.

The Imran Khan letter has not been answered in detail by the PTI in the reports available, so its full contents remain unclear beyond the points the minister addressed.

imran khan letter: At a glance
imran khan letter: At a glance
imran khan letter: Quick answers
imran khan letter: Quick answers

Questions and answers

What did Tariq Fazal Chaudhry say about the PTI founder's letter?

He called the letter, written from jail to the chief justices, false and contrary to facts. He rejected its claims on solitary confinement, medical care, court orders, books and television.

How many times has the PTI founder been medically examined, according to the minister?

The minister said the PTI founder has been taken to PIMS eight times for check-ups, and that doctors described his health as satisfactory. He added that a doctor from London also examined his blood pressure.

What relief did the minister say the PTI founder can seek?

He said the PTI founder could obtain relief only through the courts.

Image: Zacharie Grossen / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

Was this useful?Report an error
Share this storyWhatsAppFacebookXLinkedIn

More on Politics

View all →