Chaudhry Salik Sends Defamation Notices to CM Maryam and Azma Bokhari

Overseas Pakistanis Minister Chaudhry Salik Hussain has answered a Rs5 billion legal notice from Punjab's chief minister with notices of his own. The dispute began with his corruption allegations against the provincial government.

Chaudhry Salik Sends Defamation Notices to CM Maryam and Azma Bokhari
Image: Guilhem Vellut from Annecy, France / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0
At a glance
  • Chaudhry Salik Hussain says he has sent defamation notices to CM Maryam Nawaz and Information Minister Azma Bokhari.
  • He has also replied to the Rs5 billion notice Maryam served on him on November 4.
  • Salik refuses to withdraw his remarks, apologise, retract or pay any sum.
  • He says his corruption claims are a matter of public interest, not defamation.

Overseas Pakistanis Minister Chaudhry Salik Hussain has hit back at Punjab Chief Minister Maryam Nawaz with legal action of his own. On Monday he said he had sent separate Salik defamation notices to her and to Punjab Information Minister Azma Bokhari, while also replying to the Rs5 billion notice served on him earlier.

The PML-Q leader announced the move in posts on X. He said the two notices had gone out through his legal counsel, one addressed to Maryam Nawaz Sharif and the other to Azma Zahid Bokhari.

Rs5bn
damages demanded in CM Maryam's defamation notice
2
defamation notices Salik says he has sent
Sept 25
date Salik says his interview was recorded
2.5 years
time Salik says remains until the next general elections

How the row began

The dispute started after Salik appeared on a talk show on a private television channel. He praised the record of his uncle, Chaudhry Pervez Elahi, as a former chief minister of Punjab. He then criticised the present provincial administration, saying he regularly heard complaints of corruption.

He also questioned lavish public spending, singling out the use of an official aircraft. In his view, public representatives should stay mindful of the country's economic difficulties.

On November 4, Maryam Nawaz served a Rs5 billion defamation notice on him. It demanded an unconditional apology, a retraction of his statements and damages. She challenged him to produce evidence, warned of legal action if he could not, and asked why he stayed in a government he considered corrupt.

Attempts to intimidate through legal notices will neither silence nor deter me from raising concerns on matters of public interest and their well-being.

Chaudhry Salik Hussain, Minister for Overseas Pakistanis

salik defamation notices: Key numbers
salik defamation notices: Key numbers

Dispute over the Gujrat appointment

Both the chief minister and the information minister alleged that Salik's anger stemmed from a refused request. They said he had wanted a deputy commissioner of his choice in Gujrat, and that the request was turned down.

Salik rejected this. He said his interview was recorded on September 25, before the new deputy commissioner was appointed, which in his view showed the claim was wrong. He also expressed regret that the provincial government withdrew his security after the controversy.

Timeline

  1. September 25Salik's talk-show interview is recorded, according to him.
  2. November 4CM Maryam Nawaz serves a Rs5 billion defamation notice on Salik.
  3. Monday, November 16Salik replies to the notice and says he has sent defamation notices to Maryam Nawaz and Azma Bokhari.

Salik's reply to the Rs5bn notice

A copy of his reply describes his remarks as an expression of opinion on a matter of fair and public interest. It argues that they do not amount to defamation at all, and that the chief minister's notice wrongly treated them as assertions of fact.

The reply adds that defamation requires a false or untrue statement. Even if his remarks were taken as statements of fact, it says, they would not have been false. It also cites several public statements in which Maryam Nawaz herself acknowledged that corruption exists in the province.

The response goes on to say that democratically elected governments and public authorities cannot bring defamation actions under common law jurisdictions. It calls the Rs5 billion demand wholly baseless and unrelated to any genuine compensation claim. It describes the notice as legally misconceived and untenable, and says it aims to intimidate public representatives and discourage others, including the press, from speaking about corruption.

Salik states that he will not withdraw his interview remarks, apologise, publish a retraction or pay any amount.

salik defamation notices: Timeline
salik defamation notices: Timeline

Political fallout of the Salik defamation notices

Salik has repeated his allegations of gross mismanagement and rampant corruption in Punjab. He says the province needs accountability rather than intimidation, and he reaffirmed what he called a commitment to transparency in the interest of Punjab and Pakistan.

In interviews with private television channels, he rejected suggestions that his remarks were part of a conspiracy against the Punjab government. He also denied that the PML-Q was preparing to join an anti-government alliance. He noted that the next general elections are roughly two and a half years away and asked which elections Maryam Nawaz had in mind.

Asked about his brother Shafay Hussain serving as a minister in the same Punjab government, Salik replied: "Reality is reality. I stand by it and will continue to." He called Maryam Nawaz's statements about him "below the belt" and regretted that Azma Bokhari's fiery statements had worsened the row. He also described the dragging of the Chaudhry family, and particularly his father Chaudhry Shujaat Hussain, into the dispute as a below-the-belt move.

salik defamation notices: At a glance
salik defamation notices: At a glance

Questions and answers

Who has Chaudhry Salik sent defamation notices to?

He says he has sent one notice to Punjab Chief Minister Maryam Nawaz Sharif and another to Punjab Information Minister Azma Zahid Bokhari, through his legal counsel.

Why did CM Maryam serve a Rs5 billion notice on Salik?

She acted after he alleged corruption in the Punjab government. The notice demanded an unconditional apology, a retraction of his statements and damages.

Will Salik apologise or withdraw his remarks?

No. His reply to the notice says he will not withdraw his statements, apologise, publish a retraction or pay any sum.

Image: Guilhem Vellut from Annecy, France / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0

Was this useful?Report an error
Share this storyWhatsAppFacebookXLinkedIn

More on Politics

View all →