- Mustafa Kamal says Bilawal Bhutto Zardari will be responsible for any bloodshed linked to new provinces.
- He argues smaller provinces are needed for better governance and for protecting Pakistan.
- The Sindh government spokesperson called his Rs22 trillion claim baseless and demanded financial evidence.
- The spokesperson also challenged him to resign if he disagrees with the prime minister.
Federal Health Minister Mustafa Kamal has said that Pakistan People's Party (PPP) chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari will be held responsible if blood is shed over the creation of new provinces. He said Bilawal's remarks a day earlier had caused him hurt and disappointment.
In this article
The Sindh government hit back on Wednesday, rejecting his claims as political propaganda and accusing him of promoting division.
Mustafa Kamal's warning to the PPP chairman
Speaking at a press conference at the National Press Club in Islamabad, Mustafa Kamal expressed disappointment over Bilawal's statement about possible bloodshed in Karachi, Hyderabad, Mirpurkhas and Sukkur. He said those areas are predominantly inhabited by Urdu-speaking communities.
“Bilawal spoke about bloodshed in areas where Urdu-speaking people live. He is referring to violence involving the Muhajir community,” the minister said.
He recalled the violence that followed the assassination of former prime minister Benazir Bhutto in Rawalpindi, when Karachi suffered widespread destruction. Kamal claimed that Muhajir-owned businesses in Karachi and Hyderabad were deliberately set on fire, and that shops were burnt from Larkana to Karachi. He added that Muhajirs were not responsible for her assassination.
The minister said there was no need to become unnecessarily agitated over the debate on administrative units.
If even a single drop of blood is shed, Bilawal Bhutto will be responsible
Mustafa Kamal, Federal Health Minister

The case for smaller provinces
Kamal argued that creating additional administrative units is essential for running the country effectively. He said the state would ultimately have to decide whether to prioritise individual preferences or take steps to safeguard Pakistan.
He questioned why the PPP opposes new provinces if it believes it has governed Sindh well. In his view, there should be no objection even if Sindh were divided into 10 provinces with 10 chief ministers.
On the legal side, he said the Constitution already provides a procedure for creating new provinces. The 1973 Constitution, he said, is not a sacred text that cannot be changed, noting that 27 amendments have already been made.
| Issue | Mustafa Kamal's position | Sindh government's response |
|---|---|---|
| Funds for Sindh | Rs22 trillion received but services remain poor | Baseless propaganda; present financial records |
| New provinces | Needed for governance and to protect Pakistan | Division and ethnic hatred are not solutions |
| Constitutional status | 1973 Constitution can be amended | Questioning assemblies disrespects the people's mandate |
Allegations over jobs and services
The minister criticised the PPP's 18 years in power in Sindh. He claimed the 40% urban quota in government jobs is not being implemented and that fake domicile certificates are being used to deprive urban residents of employment.
He said Sindh has received Rs22 trillion since the introduction of the constitutional changes he referred to as the 18th Amendment, yet basic services remain inadequate. He cited children dying after falling into open drains, shortages of drinking water and a lack of medicines in hospitals.
Defending his record as Karachi's former mayor, Kamal claimed development projects worth Rs300 billion were carried out in his tenure. He challenged the PPP to prove that he had illegally acquired even a single yard of land in the city, and said no evidence had been produced against him since he left office in 2010.

Sindh government rejects the claims
Sindh government spokesperson Ghanwer Khan Isran said Kamal was not capable of winning even a councillor's seat. He accused the minister of politics driven by conspiracy, unrest and a desire for power, and claimed MQM ministers were trying to weaken the federation.
Isran described the Rs22 trillion figure as baseless political propaganda and demanded authentic financial evidence. He said Kamal should present financial documents and expenditure records before making allegations against the provincial government.
Referring to Kamal's remarks on the constitutional status of provincial assemblies, Isran asked: “If the provincial assemblies are unconstitutional, under which Constitution does your federal ministry exist?” He said questioning the assemblies amounted to disrespecting the mandate of the people of all four provinces.
The spokesperson also said dividing provinces, promoting ethnic hatred and political blackmail are not solutions to urban problems. He urged the MQM not to undermine Sindh's peace and unity for its political survival, and challenged Kamal to resign from the federal cabinet if he disagrees with the prime minister.

Questions and answers
What did Mustafa Kamal say about Bilawal Bhutto Zardari?
He said Bilawal would be responsible for any bloodshed over new provinces and that Bilawal's remarks about possible violence in Sindh's cities had disappointed and hurt him.
How did the Sindh government respond?
Spokesperson Ghanwer Khan Isran called the Rs22 trillion claim baseless, demanded financial evidence, accused Kamal of promoting division and challenged him to resign if he disagrees with the prime minister.
Why does Kamal support new provinces?
He says smaller provinces are necessary to improve governance and protect Pakistan, and that the Constitution already provides a procedure for creating them.
Image: Ktownboy103 / Wikimedia Commons, CC0




