FCC rebukes LDA for dragging Rashid Minhas family into land dispute

The Federal Constitutional Court has thrown out the Lahore Development Authority's appeal over a Gulberg-III plot. It also told the authority to stop spending public money on pointless cases against individuals.

FCC rebukes LDA for dragging Rashid Minhas family into land dispute
At a glance
  • The FCC dismissed the LDA's appeal against a Lahore High Court judgment of March 5, 2018.
  • The dispute concerns a 14-marla plot in Gulberg-III, Lahore, and a consent decree of May 7, 2005.
  • The court said the decree had attained finality and the LDA's objections were frivolous.
  • The LDA's director general must ensure public money is not wasted on such litigation.

The Federal Constitutional Court (FCC) has sharply rebuked the Lahore Development Authority (LDA) for pulling the Rashid Minhas family into a long-running land dispute. The court dismissed the authority's appeal and told its director general to stop spending public money on pointless cases against individuals.

Pilot Officer Rashid Minhas Shaheed of the Pakistan Air Force was awarded the Nishan-i-Haider, the country's highest military gallantry award. The case was brought against his brother, Farooq Minhas, who was the respondent.

14 marla
size of the disputed Gulberg-III plot
3
lower courts that had rejected the LDA's objections
3
judges on the FCC bench

What the FCC decided

A three-member bench headed by Justice Ali Baqar Najafi, with Justice Rozi Khan Barrech and Justice Syed Arshad Hussain Shah, rejected the LDA's appeal. The appeal challenged a Lahore High Court (LHC) judgment of March 5, 2018, which went in favour of Farooq Minhas.

The LHC had directed the LDA to stop claiming ownership of the land in question, which had already become part of the Gulberg-III scheme. The authority then approached the Supreme Court, which dismissed its petition. That court held that the LDA had no ownership rights over the land, since the Settlement Department had already transferred it to the occupants.

Justice Najafi, who wrote the judgment, regretted that the LDA had kept pulling the family of the martyred officer into litigation over a property matter. He observed: "The family is facing the agony perpetuated by the LDA by dragging them in the courts in frivolous litigation."

We, therefore, deem it appropriate that, instead of imposing costs, we direct the Director General, LDA, to ensure that the authority does not deplete its resources or public money on frivolous, vexatious and obnoxious litigation against individuals.

Justice Ali Baqar Najafi, Federal Constitutional Court

rashid minhas family: Key numbers
rashid minhas family: Key numbers

How the dispute began

The matter goes back to a consent decree passed in favour of Farooq Minhas on May 7, 2005. When the decree was being executed, the LDA raised objections. It argued that the 14-marla plot in Gulberg-III was evacuee property acquired by the authority for the development of the scheme.

According to the LDA, its predecessor, the Lahore Improvement Trust, paid the award amount to the custodian of evacuee property and took physical possession on Dec 24, 1955. It also said the plot fell within the boundaries of a notification issued on Aug 6, 1953, and that the Land Acquisition Collector's award of Oct 30, 1962, had been finalised.

The authority further argued that no exemption or adjustment had been granted to Nawab Mirza and Maqsooda Begum, the predecessors-in-interest of the respondent. It also questioned a sale deed of March 7, 1976, under which Maqsooda Begum acquired the property from Nawab Mirza.

Timeline

  1. Aug 6, 1953Notification issued covering the Gulberg-III scheme boundaries, as cited by the LDA
  2. Dec 24, 1955LDA says its predecessor took physical possession of the land
  3. Oct 30, 1962Land Acquisition Collector announces the award
  4. June 8, 1966Property Transfer Document No. 213 issued by the Deputy Settlement Commissioner
  5. March 7, 1976Sale deed from Nawab Mirza to Maqsooda Begum
  6. Aug 17, 1980Vigilance Commission decision on honouring verified transfer orders
  7. May 7, 2005Consent decree passed in favour of Farooq Minhas
  8. March 5, 2018LHC judgment in favour of Farooq Minhas

Why the LDA's objections failed

Nawab Mirza had claimed ownership on the basis of Property Transfer Document No. 213, issued by the Deputy Settlement Commissioner on June 8, 1966. That was four years after the 1962 award. The LDA said the transaction was against policy.

The FCC noted that the executing court, the revisional court and the LHC had all rejected these objections. Justice Najafi observed that the appeal challenged the concurrent findings of those three courts. The court held that the earlier decisions and the decree had attained finality, especially because the consent decree was passed on the LDA's own "no objection".

The bench added that a declaration had also been granted in favour of the legal heirs of Maqsooda Begum. It found that the objections raised under Order XXI of the Code of Civil Procedure were frivolous and outside the scope of an executing court.

rashid minhas family: Timeline
rashid minhas family: Timeline

Vigilance Commission decision of 1980

The FCC also referred to a decision of the Vigilance Commission dated Aug 17, 1980. It stated that duly verified transfer orders would be honoured by the LDA and that only development charges would be recovered from the transferees.

The court noted that the authority had accepted that decision and acted on it, with its director general issuing the necessary directions.

Warning on public money

The court chose not to impose costs on the LDA. Instead it gave a direction to the authority's head, which it considered more appropriate. Justice Najafi observed that the director general must ensure the authority does not waste its resources or public funds on meritless cases against individuals.

The ruling closes a dispute that has run through several courts. It also sends a clear message on how public bodies should treat the Rashid Minhas family and other individuals.

rashid minhas family: At a glance
rashid minhas family: At a glance

Questions and answers

What did the FCC decide in the Rashid Minhas family case?

A three-member bench dismissed the LDA's appeal against the LHC's March 5, 2018, judgment, which had gone in favour of Farooq Minhas, the brother of Pilot Officer Rashid Minhas Shaheed.

Did the court fine the LDA?

No. Instead of imposing costs, the court directed the LDA's director general to ensure the authority does not waste public money on frivolous litigation against individuals.

What was the dispute about?

It concerned a 14-marla plot in Gulberg-III, Lahore. The LDA claimed it was evacuee property acquired for the scheme, but the courts held that its objections to the 2005 consent decree had no merit.

Was this useful?Report an error
Share this storyWhatsAppFacebookXLinkedIn

More on Courts & Law

View all →