Khawaja Asif, Talal Chaudhry Hit Back at Bilawal Over New Provinces Row

Defence Minister Khawaja Asif and Minister of State Talal Chaudhry have answered PPP chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari's speech point by point. The exchange shows the strain between coalition partners PML-N and PPP over new provinces and constitutional changes.

Khawaja Asif, Talal Chaudhry Hit Back at Bilawal Over New Provinces Row
Image: Usman.pg / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0
At a glance
  • Khawaja Asif questioned the PPP's moral standing, citing its 18 years in power in Sindh and its partnership with the PML-N since 2022.
  • Asif appeared to back a referendum on new provinces, saying public opinion should be sought alongside Parliament.
  • Talal Chaudhry accused Bilawal of disowning the 27th Amendment after taking credit for it.
  • Health Minister Mustafa Kamal said the PPP had blocked MQM-P's push for new administrative units.

Defence Minister Khawaja Asif has told PPP chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari that anyone seeking fairness must first show clean hands. The remark came on Wednesday, a day after Bilawal's hard-hitting speech criticising the government.

Other PML-N figures joined the response, and the Bilawal speech row appears to be deepening the divide between the two coalition partners. The dispute covers new provinces, constitutional changes and the treatment of the opposition.

18 years
PPP's time in power in Sindh, as cited by Khawaja Asif
250 million
people Asif says hold the right to participate in governance
3 + GB
provinces and region where the PPP is in power, per Talal Chaudhry
27th
Constitutional Amendment at the centre of the dispute

What Bilawal said

Bilawal's speech, delivered at the Karachi Press Club, called for a "political reset" and criticised the government's handling of governance and constitutional matters. He also voiced support for several opposition demands, including the release of jailed former prime minister Imran Khan, according to the reports.

On the creation of new provinces, he referred to Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi's suggestion of a referendum. He said: "In our history, a referendum has always been carried out for an undemocratic act and never a democratic one." He also warned that dividing Sindh against the wishes of its people could lead to bloodshed.

Bilawal further said the system of governance had not collapsed but had been "made to collapse". This appeared to be a response to Naqvi's statement in July that the system had "collapsed" and needed a "reset".

He who claims equity must come with clean hands.

Khawaja Asif, Defence Minister

bilawal speech row: Key numbers
bilawal speech row: Key numbers

Asif's reply: "clean hands"

In a post on X, Asif said: "He who claims equity must come with clean hands." He called it a centuries-old maxim and asked whether Bilawal had the right to lecture or threaten.

Asif noted that the PPP has governed Sindh for 18 years. He said sarcastically that Sindh had "turned into paradise" and that the world admired the condition of Karachi. He also said the PPP had been a partner of the PML-N in government since 2022, adding: "You get the profit and the PML-N and Pakistan suffer loss".

On the reset debate, Asif said no system could be reset without public support. He said a "system reset" would certainly be debated in Parliament, but the public could not be "deprived of its fundamental right". He added: "The pinnacle of legitimacy would be reached if the public opinion is also taken into account along with that of Parliament."

He also said that holding politicians to account was nothing new and that no politician was exempt. Closing his remarks, he said: "Governance is not anyone’s monopoly; Allah has granted this right to 250 million people."

Talal Chaudhry on the 27th Amendment

Minister of State for Interior Talal Chaudhry said Bilawal presented himself as a champion of the Constitution but that his performance in practice was "zero". He pointed out that the PPP is in power in three provinces and Gilgit-Baltistan, and that the president and Senate chairperson are also from the party. In his view, this made it odd for Bilawal to speak as if he were the opposition leader.

Chaudhry took issue with Bilawal's remark that the 27th Amendment was passed "with brute majority". He recalled Bilawal's National Assembly speech in which he called a constitutional court Quaid-i-Azam's dream and described the change as the PPP's legacy. "Sins are not washed away in this manner. You cannot dissociate yourself in this manner," he said.

He also challenged the warning of bloodshed in Sindh. "The question is: does casting a vote cause blood to flow, or does it stop bloodshed? You always say the decision should come through the ballot, not the bullet. So when did you start fearing the vote?" he asked.

Chaudhry alleged that the PPP opposed new provinces to keep control over resources. He also questioned why a unit with good governance should be divided while those with poor governance were left intact. He said amendments had been made over time to improve governance and that such changes would continue as circumstances evolved.

bilawal speech row: At a glance
bilawal speech row: At a glance

MQM-P adds its voice

Health Minister Mustafa Kamal, whose party has also demanded new administrative units, questioned why the PPP was worried if its record in government had been good. Speaking at a press conference in Islamabad, he painted a bleak picture of Sindh and said power should be devolved to the provinces.

He said the Muttahida Qaumi Movement-Pakistan had tried to achieve this through the 26th and 27th Constitutional Amendments, "but the PPP crushed" the move.

What happens next

Asif said a "system reset" would be debated in Parliament. No date for any debate or any referendum on new provinces was given in the reports.

bilawal speech row: In their words
bilawal speech row: In their words

Questions and answers

What did Khawaja Asif say to Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari?

Asif said that anyone claiming equity must come with clean hands. He questioned the PPP's record in Sindh, where it has governed for 18 years, and noted its partnership with the PML-N since 2022.

Does Asif support a referendum on new provinces?

He appeared to. He said the public could not be deprived of its fundamental right and that legitimacy would peak if public opinion were taken into account alongside Parliament's.

Why is Talal Chaudhry criticising Bilawal over the 27th Amendment?

Chaudhry said Bilawal took credit for the amendment in the National Assembly but now says votes were cast under force. He said a party cannot dissociate itself from a vote in that way.

Image: Usman.pg / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0

Was this useful?Report an error
Share this storyWhatsAppFacebookXLinkedIn

More on Politics

View all →