Bilawal Seeks Political Reset, Says System ‘Deliberately Destroyed’

PPP chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari says Pakistan's system did not collapse by accident and needs a reset led by politicians. He also warned against dividing Sindh by force and criticised the federal government over provincial finances.

Bilawal Seeks Political Reset, Says System ‘Deliberately Destroyed’
At a glance
  • Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari says the system was 'deliberately destroyed' and needs a political, not non-political, reset.
  • He opposes any division of Sindh by force and rejects a referendum as an unconstitutional route.
  • He plans to try to convene a round-table conference or APC on the system's collapse and reset.
  • Information Minister Attaullah Tarar defended the referendum idea, while the JUI-F backed Bilawal's stance on provinces.

Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) Chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari has called for a Bilawal political reset of the country's system, saying its decline was deliberate rather than accidental. Speaking at the Karachi Press Club, he said the process must be led by politicians and must restore public confidence in institutions.

He also warned that dividing Sindh by force would bring enmity and bloodshed, and he accepted that he shared some of the blame for the state of the system.

Rs1.7tr
Provinces' share of the petroleum levy, per Bilawal
16 years
Since the 18th Amendment, with provincial funds still not received, he said
10 times
Sindh Assembly's stated position on dividing Sindh, per Bilawal

What the Bilawal political reset proposal involves

Bilawal said the system had not failed by itself. He named parliament, the election commission, the judiciary and the media among the institutions whose confidence needed to be rebuilt. He said restoring public trust was the first requirement of any reset.

He insisted the reset must involve elected representatives. "This system needs a reset, but the reset will not be non-political; it will be political," he said. He added that he too was at fault, because every person makes mistakes and those mistakes must be corrected.

The PPP chairman said he would try to convene a round-table conference or an all parties conference (APC) on the destroyed system and its reset. The aim, he said, was for all parties to build consensus so that inflation and poverty could be ended.

He said the change should begin in parliament, where opposition leaders had real reasons for feeling a lack of confidence. "The most patriotic job in any parliament is the job of the opposition," he said, urging the ruling side to restore the opposition's trust.

I believe the system has not collapsed; it has been deliberately destroyed.

Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari, PPP Chairman

bilawal political reset: Key numbers
bilawal political reset: Key numbers

Imran Khan, PTI and the opposition

Bilawal said he considered PTI founder Imran Khan a "political prisoner" and believed the party faced political victimisation. He also said some of PTI's difficulties stemmed from its own mistakes and actions.

He said the government must acknowledge PTI's political presence, arguing that the country could not be managed without recognising its stake. He also wanted to see a day when no prime minister is jailed after leaving office, though he said this would require consensus.

On JUI-F chief Maulana Fazlur Rehman, Bilawal said the government should answer his questions even if it disliked them. He questioned why action through the National Accountability Bureau and an anti-encroachment drive followed Fazl's criticism of the government.

Bilawal said electoral rigging should be addressed as part of the reset so that conditions for the next elections could be improved. He argued that this could also help restore the confidence of PTI and other opposition parties.

Reactions to Bilawal's remarks
Party or figure Position
Information Minister Attaullah Tarar Calls a referendum constitutional and says the provinces debate should continue
MQM-Pakistan Says new provinces are a constitutional requirement
JUI-F Calls Bilawal's statement realistic and shares his stance on provinces
Raja Nasir Abbas (MWM) Ready for talks on rolling back the 26th and 27th amendments through parliament

Warning over dividing Sindh

Bilawal said the PPP supports new provinces only if they are created in line with the people's wishes, the Constitution and the law. "We do not want division through force," he said. He warned that forced division would divide society and that bloodshed would not be limited to a single death.

He said the Constitution already lays down a procedure and that suggesting a referendum amounted to seeking an unconstitutional method. Referring to a provincial minister's call for one, he said: "Hold a referendum in your own assembly first." He added that the Sindh Assembly had stated its position on dividing Sindh "not once, but ten times".

He said he had not been consulted on the creation of provinces, and that neither the prime minister nor the cabinet had said anything on the matter. In his words, "When such things are done through back doors, they do not last forever."

bilawal political reset: At a glance
bilawal political reset: At a glance

Economy and provincial finances

Bilawal said Pakistan's people had never faced difficulties like those of today, with poverty, unemployment and inflation rising rapidly. "I am frightened about what will happen to the people under these circumstances," he said.

He said 16 years had passed since the 18th Amendment, yet the provinces still had not received their financial resources. He put the provinces' share of the petroleum levy at about Rs1.7 trillion. He also said the federal government should explain why money was not being spent on the people, and that authority over rare minerals lay with the provinces.

He said he had invited Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif to sit down with the Sindh government and proposed holding federal cabinet meetings in every province. He said he had backed Shehbaz Sharif for prime minister and wanted him to succeed, but that the premier needed enough authority to control his ministers.

On Balochistan, he said terrorism had reached alarming levels, but that poverty, inflation and unemployment were also behind it. He added that suspended trade with Iran and Afghanistan had deepened the province's economic hardship.

Reactions from government and parties

Information Minister Attaullah Tarar asked: "Isn't enjoying the power and doing opposition at the same time a blatant contradiction?" He described a referendum as the best way to gauge public opinion and said the debate on provinces should continue as a democratic and legal requirement.

Senate Opposition Leader Allama Raja Nasir Abbas of the Majlis Wahdatul Muslimeen said his side was ready for talks on rolling back the 26th and 27th constitutional amendments through parliament. An MQM-Pakistan spokesperson said new provinces were a constitutional requirement, while JUI-F spokesperson Aslam Ghauri called Bilawal's statement realistic and said his party shared the PPP's stance on dividing provinces.

What happens next

Bilawal said he would try to convene a round-table conference or APC on the system's collapse and reset.

bilawal political reset: In their words
bilawal political reset: In their words

Questions and answers

What is the Bilawal political reset proposal?

Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari wants a reset of the system led by politicians and elected representatives, starting with restoring public confidence in institutions. He plans to try to convene a round-table conference or APC on the issue.

Does the PPP support new provinces?

The PPP says it supports provinces created in line with the people's wishes, the Constitution and the law. It opposes division through force or coercion, and it rejects a referendum as an unconstitutional method.

How did the government respond?

Information Minister Attaullah Tarar said a referendum is a constitutional procedure and the best way to ascertain public opinion. He also said the debate on provinces should continue.

Was this useful?Report an error
Share this storyWhatsAppFacebookXLinkedIn

More on Politics

View all →